Skip to content
Linespedia

Five Criticisms - IV.

Topics: classic

(On Certain Realists.)     You with the quick sardonic eye     For all the mockeries of life,     Beware, in this dark masque of things that seem,     Lest even that tragic irony,     Which you discern in this our mortal strife,     Trick you and trap you, also, with a dream.     Last night I saw a dead man borne along     The city streets, passing a boisterous throng     That never ceased to laugh and shout and dance:     And yet, and yet,     For all the poison bitter minds might brew     From themes like this, I knew     That the stern Truth would not permit her glance     Thus to be foiled by flying straws of chance,     For her keen eyes on deeper skies are set,     And laws that tragic ironists forget.     She saw the dead man's life, from birth to death,--     All that he knew of love and sin and pain,     Success and failure (not as this world sees),     His doubts, his passions, inner loss and gain,     And borne on darker tides of constant law     Beyond the margin of this life she saw     All that had left his body with the breath.     These things, to her, were still realities.     If any mourned for him unseen,     She saw them, too.     If none, she'd not pretend     His clay were colder, or his God less true,     Or that his grave, at length, would be less green.     She'd not deny     The boundless depths of her eternal sky     Brooding above a boundless universe,     Because he seemed to man's unseeing eye     Going a little further to fare worse;     Nor would she assume he lacked that unseen friend     Whom even the tragic ironists declare     Were better than the seen, in his last end.     Oh, then, beware, beware,     Lest in the strong name of "reality"     You mock yourselves anew with shapes of air,     Lest it be you, agnostics, who re-write     The fettering creeds of night,     Affirm you know your own Unknowable,     And lock the wingd soul in a new hell;     Lest it be you, lip-worshippers of Truth,     Who break the heart of youth;     Lest it be you, the realists, who fight     With shadows, and forget your own pure light;     Lest it be you who, with a little shroud     Snatched from the sightless faces of the dead,     Hoodwink the world, and keep the mourner bowed     In dust, real dust, with stones, real stones, for bread;     Lest, as you look one eighth of an inch beneath     The yellow skin of death,     You dream yourselves discoverers of the skull     That old memento mori of our faith;     Lest it be you who hunt a flying wraith     Through this dissolving stuff of hill and cloud;     Lest it be you, who, at the last, annul     Your covenant with your kind;     Lest it be you who darken heart and mind,     Sell the strong soul in bondage to a dream,     And fetter us once more to things that seem.

AI analysis available. Enable JavaScript to interact.

About this line

"(On Certain Realists.)..."

Exploring the themes of classic, Alfred Noyes delivers a powerful performance in "Five Criticisms - IV."... ### Why We Love This Line At Linespedia, we believe that poetry is the ultimate sanctuary for the soul...

Classified Tags

Related lines

"(Written after the British Service at Trinity Church, New York)     I.     Before those golden altar-lights we stood,         Each one of us rem"

"This is the song of the wind as it came     Tossing the flags of the nations to flame:             I am the breath of God. I am His laughter."

"The very best ship that ever I knew,         --Ah-way O, to me O--     Was a big black trawler with a deep-sea crew--         Sing, my bullies,"

"(An Answer)     [After reading an article in a leading London journal by an "intellectual" who attacked one of the noblest poets and greatest ar"

"Here morning in the ploughman's songs is met     Ere yet one footstep shows in all the sky,     And twilight in the east, a doubt as yet,     S"

"The Text is taken from Percy's Reliques (1765), vol. i. p. 71, 'given from two MS. copies, transmitted from Scotland.' Herd had a very similar bal"

Continue Reading

"(Written after the British Service at Trinity Chur..."

Weekly Poetic Insight

Join our literary Sanctuary

Get the most inspiring lines, poetic analysis, and secret shayaris delivered to your inbox every Sunday.